- Home
- Current
Current Featured Cigars - October 2025
Our 9-member Cigar Rating Panel smokes over 200 cigars a week, rating each for proper construction, appearance, aroma, smoke volume and flavor profile. We smoke a lot of bitter, harsh, improperly aged and poorly constructed cigars so you don’t have to! Less than 5% of those considered ever make it to you.
Discover this month’s highly-rated cigar selections for each of our 2 Distinct Cigar Clubs using the chart below. Or, view all of our Past Selections.
| Featured Cigars | Original Premium Cigar Club | The Rare Cigar Club | ||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 5 cigars per month | 4 cigars per month | |||||
| Erin Go Bragh Irish Whiskey Toro |  | |||||
| Drew Estate Undercrown Maduro Gran Toro |  | |||||
| HC Series Maduro Gordo |  | |||||
| Brazilian Cream Torpedo |  | |||||
| EP Carrillo New Wave Brilliantes |  | |||||
| Graycliff 10-Year Vintage Maduro Pirate Torpedo |  | |||||
| Oliva Master Blends III Robusto |  | |||||
| Partagas y Nada Mas Santiago Robusto |  | |||||
| Rocky Patel Vintage 20th Anniversary Toro |  | 
Please Note: We don’t offer substitutions for our monthly selections. However, if you have specific style preferences, feel free to explore our Cigar Store, where you’ll find a wide range of individual options.
 
        Outstanding Values On Top-Rated Cigars
                Our purchasing power allows us to offer exceptional reorder values on highly rated 
 cigars such as
                Rocky Patel's Decade Torpedo, rated 95 in Cigar Aficionado.
            
- Country: Dominican Republic
- Shape: Toro
- Size: 6.0 x 50
- Strength (1-10): 2
- Panel Rating: 91
Raise a glass — or in this case, a cigar — to Ireland with the Erin Go Bragh Irish Whiskey Toro. Draped in a smooth, golden-brown Connecticut Shade wrapper and finished with a band in orange, white, and green, this cigar proudly wears its heritage on its sleeve. Its name means “Ireland Forever”, and true to form it’s gently infused with authentic Irish whiskey. Rather than overwhelming the palate, the infusion plays a subtle role, most...
- Country: Nicaragua
- Shape: Grand Toro
- Size: 6.0 x 52
- Strength (1-10): 8
- Panel Rating: 95
Born from the ingenuity of Drew Estate’s factory rollers, Undercrown is a cigar with rebellion in its DNA. When Liga Privada #9 became too scarce for the rollers to smoke, they crafted their own secret blend — and what they created was too good to keep quiet. The Gran Toro struts a dark, oily San Andrés maduro wrapper over a hearty Connecticut Stalk Cut Habano binder, packed with rich Brazilian and Nicaraguan long-fillers. From...
- Country: Honduras
- Shape: Gordo
- Size: 6.0 x 58
- Strength (1-10): 8
- Panel Rating: 93
You may know Xikar for their lifetime-guaranteed cigar tools, but over the past decade they’ve quietly made a splash with their own premium cigar line—and the HC Series Maduro is a standout. Its band, emblazoned with palm trees, nods to the El Corojo farm in Cuba—the birthplace of the tobacco style that inspired parts of this blend. Debuted in 2009, the HC Maduro Gordo wears a dark, silky Connecticut Broadleaf wrapper over a...
- Country: Nicaragua
- Shape: Torpedo
- Size: 6.5 x 52
- Strength (1-10): 5
- Panel Rating: 92
Looking for a handmade cigar that’s mellow, creamy, and easy to enjoy any time of day? The Brazilian Cream Torpedo is just the ticket. Rolled in Nicaragua, it features a hearty golden-brown Brazilian wrapper over a Nicaraguan binder, with a “Cuban sandwich” filler blend of Nicaraguan tobaccos — a technique that combines short fillers wrapped in long filler leaves for a balanced, reliable burn. Medium in body, this torpedo delivers...
- Country: Dominican Republic
- Shape: Robusto
- Size: 5.0 x 50
- Strength (1-10): 4
- Panel Rating: 96
From the legendary blender Ernesto Perez-Carrillo, the New Wave Brilliantes is a shining example of his mastery with Connecticut-wrapped cigars. Crafted at the Tabacalera La Alianza factory in the Dominican Republic, this classic 5 x 50 robusto showcases a silky-smooth Ecuadorian Connecticut wrapper, a Nicaraguan binder, and a balanced core of Nicaraguan long-fillers. True to its name, it lights up with a wave of creamy, approachable...
- Country: Honduras
- Shape: Torpedo
- Size: 6.5 x 54
- Strength (1-10): 5
- Panel Rating: 92
The 10-Year Vintage Maduro Pirate is a shining example of that legacy. This medium to full-bodied torpedo is dressed in a dark, oily Connecticut Broadleaf Maduro wrapper that has been extensively aged for refinement. Beneath, a Honduran binder secures a balanced mix of long-fillers from Honduras and Nicaragua, delivering a smoke that is rich, complex, and endlessly satisfying. From the first draw, you’ll find billows of...
- Country: Nicaragua
- Shape: Robusto
- Size: 5.0 x 50
- Strength (1-10): 8
- Panel Rating: 96
In the heart of Nicaragua, the Oliva family has built a legacy as one of the top growers and blenders in the world, and the Master Blends series is their crown jewel—limited, artisanal runs crafted from elite tobacco batches reserved for those who demand the best. The Master Blends III (MB3) is the third iteration in that tradition, distinguished by its rarity and unrelenting quality. This version comes clothed in a rich Connecticut...
- Country: Dominican Republic
- Shape: Robusto
- Size: 5.0 x 50
- Strength (1-10): 5
- Panel Rating: 95
The Partagás Y Nada Más Santiago Robusto is a fresh chapter in Partagás lore—launched by Forged Cigar Co. in 2025 and rolled at Tabacalera William Ventura in Santiago, Dominican Republic. Its name, Y Nada Más, means “and nothing else,” a declarative nod to uncompromised quality. The blend features a Habano 2000 wrapper, Sumatra binder, and a complex filler mélange of Piloto Cubano, Corojo, Ecuadorian, and Broadleaf tobaccos. Reviews describe...
- Country: Honduras
- Shape: Toro
- Size: 6.0 x 50
- Strength (1-10): 9
- Panel Rating: 95
Rocky Patel, once an entertainment lawyer turned cigar visionary, has built a brand synonymous with precision and excellence. With the Vintage 20th Anniversary line, he pays tribute to the blending tradition he launched decades ago. This edition features a 12-year aged Connecticut Broadleaf wrapper over a Brazilian binder and Nicaraguan long-fillers, capturing both smoothness and depth. (The Vintage 20th was lauded with a...
 
        We’re so proud of our featured cigars that we list them going all the way back to 1997
No other Cigar Club can claim the same. Check out what we’ve been up for the last 20+ years. We know you’ll be impressed enough to see what’s coming next month.
See past selections 
        Outstanding Values On Top-Rated Cigars
                Our purchasing power allows us to offer exceptional reorder values on highly rated 
 cigars such as
                Rocky Patel's Decade Torpedo, rated 95 in Cigar Aficionado.
            
                         
                         Rated Customer Service
                        Rated Customer Service
                    
                    
                        Assuring satisfaction to over 2,000,000 CUSTOMERS since 1994 has earned us a Better Business Bureau
                        
                        rating. A BBB business since 10/05/2005.
                    
100% Satisfaction Guarantee
Our 100% satisfaction guarantee ensures that every item you purchase at MonthlyClubs meets your high standards or you can return all product for a replacement or refund.












