- Home
- Current
Current Featured Cigars - December 2025
Our 9-member Cigar Rating Panel smokes over 200 cigars a week, rating each for proper construction, appearance, aroma, smoke volume and flavor profile. We smoke a lot of bitter, harsh, improperly aged and poorly constructed cigars so you don’t have to! Less than 5% of those considered ever make it to you.
Discover this month’s highly-rated cigar selections for each of our 2 Distinct Cigar Clubs using the chart below. Or, view all of our Past Selections.
Featured Cigars |
Original Premium Cigar Club
|
The Rare Cigar Club
|
||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
|
5 cigars per month |
4 cigars per month |
|||||
| Bahia Maduro No. 2 Torpedo |
|
|||||
| Gran Habano Vintage 2006 Habano Robusto |
|
|||||
| Brioso Maduro Gigante |
|
|||||
| Kristoff Connecticut Matador |
|
|||||
| Cuba Libre The Brute |
|
|||||
| Man O' War Ruination 10th Anniversary Box Pressed Gordo |
|
|||||
| H. Upmann The Banker Annuity |
|
|||||
| La Palina 1948 Toro |
|
|||||
| CAO Black Gothic Torpedo |
|
Please Note: We don’t offer substitutions for our monthly selections. However, if you have specific style preferences, feel free to explore our Cigar Store, where you’ll find a wide range of individual options.
Outstanding Values On Top-Rated Cigars
Our purchasing power allows us to offer exceptional reorder values on highly rated
cigars such as
Rocky Patel's Decade Torpedo, rated 95 in Cigar Aficionado.
- Country: Nicaragua
- Shape: Torpedo
- Size: 6.0 x 54
- Strength (1-10): 6
- Panel Rating: 93
Tony Borhani, founder of Bahia cigars, takes his business seriously. In a personal quest for stogie knowledge, he spent three years exploring cigar territory in Central and South America. He met growers, rollers and master blenders, studying their methods and styles. To this day, he constantly combines his knowledge of traditional production techniques with new ideas and secret methods that extend the art of processing, curing, aging and...
- Country: Honduras
- Shape: Robusto
- Size: 5.0 x 50
- Strength (1-10): 4
- Panel Rating: 93
Guillermo Rico has been a leaf broker, a grower, and such an accomplished catador (cigar taster) that he reportedly can differentiate five different leaves in a single blend. Born in Cubita, Colombia to a family of tobacco growers, he and his son George own the Gran Habano and GR Tabacaleras Unidas line of cigars. They established their Danli, Honduras factory, La Perla Hondureña, in 1966, initially producing cigars for Alec Bradley and other...
- Country: Nicaragua
- Shape: Gigante
- Size: 6.0 x 60
- Strength (1-10): 4
- Panel Rating: 92
The Brioso Maduro Gigante was manufactured by the famed General Cigar Company which is behind some of the best cigars in the world like Cohiba, Macanudo, and CAO, to name a few, and Brioso cigars are held to the same strict quality control. Hailing from Nicaragua, this weighty 60-ring gauge smoke features a dark Maduro wrapper, a habano binder, and a blend of Dominican seco and ligero tobaccos with Nicaraguan and Mexican long-fillers. Give...
- Country: Dominican Republic
- Shape: Gordo
- Size: 6.5 x 56
- Strength (1-10): 3
- Panel Rating: 95
Kristoff has built its reputation on boutique craftsmanship, Cuban-inspired presentation, and blends that balance refinement with flavor. The Connecticut line showcases the softer side of the brand, offering a mild-to-medium cigar that remains complex, well-constructed, and unmistakably Kristoff. Founded in 2004 by Glen Case, Kristoff continues to handcraft cigars using traditional methods, and the Connecticut Matador is no exception. With...
- Country: Honduras
- Shape: Gordo
- Size: 4.5 x 60
- Strength (1-10): 5
- Panel Rating: 92
Cuba Libre One is hand-crafted by Nestor Plasencia in his massive Nicaraguan factory that produces delicious super-premiums for more brands than you can even fathom. Fortunately, he has the manpower and the resources to make each and every cigar perfect no matter how many are made. Note the crisp, glossy white band with impressive silver and blue accents on this ultra-bold, mega-flavorful cigar—it really jumps off the dark Honduran Habano...
- Country: Nicaragua
- Shape: Gordo
- Size: 6.0 x 60
- Strength (1-10): 9
- Panel Rating: 95
Ten years ago, Man O’ War started coming out of A.J. Fernandez’s factory and ever since has been taking the cigar world by storm. The substantial and elegant bands on the Man O’ War aren’t just window dressing. Full-bodied aficionados are going to love this handsome stogie: a supremely flavorful and superbly constructed handmade that’s an absolute powder keg. Before you even light this brown beauty, hold it awhile, because it’s not every day...
- Country: Nicaragua
- Shape: Toro
- Size: 6.0 x 52
- Strength (1-10): 4
- Panel Rating: 93
The Banker in your shipment today requires us to travel back to Cuba in 1844. One of the blends they made was so good, unique, and exceptional, they decided to lock that one away in their bank vault only to give out to their most important (wealthiest) clients. While that original blend is long gone, several attempts were made to recreate it, and finally this award winning blend is back for us to enjoy! Starting from the inside is a vintage...
- Country: Nicaragua
- Shape: Toro
- Size: 6.0 x 52
- Strength (1-10): 5
- Panel Rating: 95
Debuting at the 2023 PCA Convention & Trade Show (Premium Cigar Association), La Palina teamed up with Oliva to celebrate the 75th birthday of Bill Paley. Handcrafted at Oliva’s Tabolisa factory in Estelí, Nicaragua, this smoke is months in the making to ensure it exceeds expectations. Starting from the inside, this smoke features Nicaraguan fillers, a Nicaraguan binder, and a stunning Ecuadoran Sumatra wrapper leaf. Once lit, the smoke...
- Country: Honduras
- Shape: Torpedo
- Size: 6.0 x 52
- Strength (1-10): 5
- Panel Rating: 92
The CAO Black in your shipment today is one of CAO’s earliest nationally distributed blends and can only be found at a handful of selected retailers. Handmade in Honduras, each stogie is individually wrapped. The cigar starts with a stunning dark brown Connecticut-seed wrapper grown in Ecuador, is bound with a zesty Nicaraguan Habano leaf, and is finished with a well-aged three country blend from Honduras, Mexico, and Nicaragua. Remove...
We’re so proud of our featured cigars that we list them going all the way back to 1997
No other Cigar Club can claim the same. Check out what we’ve been up for the last 20+ years. We know you’ll be impressed enough to see what’s coming next month.
See past selections
Outstanding Values On Top-Rated Cigars
Our purchasing power allows us to offer exceptional reorder values on highly rated
cigars such as
Rocky Patel's Decade Torpedo, rated 95 in Cigar Aficionado.
Rated Customer Service
Assuring satisfaction to over 2,000,000 CUSTOMERS since 1994 has earned us a Better Business Bureau
rating. A BBB business since 10/05/2005.
100% Satisfaction Guarantee
Our 100% Satisfaction Guarantee ensures that every product you purchase from any of our clubs meets your high standards, contact us within 30 days and we will do our best to make it right or you may cancel your membership at anytime and receive a full refund for any unshipped product.












