Skip to next element

FREE SHIPPING ON MONTHLY SUBSCRIPTIONS

The Rare Cigar Club

Rare, Hand-rolled, Small Batch Cigars

$61.95/mo Free shipping included

Your membership will include:

  • Four Hand-rolled, Rare, Small-Batch Cigars each month from the world's top producers using the highest quality aged tobaccos. Each shipment features four different, top-rated cigars of varying shapes, sizes, and tobacco blends, hand-crafted by extremely limited-production, boutique manufacturers, as well as cigars from super-premium brands.
  • Our Monthly Newsletter with detailed tasting notes, cigar profiles, manufacturer histories, and suggested drink pairings.
  • Free shipping included
Use arrow keys to navigate between optionsHow would you like to pay?

The Rare Cigar Club

For the most discerning cigar lovers, we offer The Rare Cigar Club. Each shipment features four different and extremely limited-production hand-rolled cigars. Made with the highest quality aged tobaccos and typically boasting retail values between $12-$25 per cigar, The Rare Cigar Club is the ultimate cigar experience for when only the best will do!

These small-batch cigars are selected from boutique manufacturers like Alec Bradley and Carlos Toraño, as well as highly-rated super-premium brands like Graycliff, Macanudo and Cohiba. Members always get a variety of lengths, gauges, wrapper types, and tobacco blends.

Every shipment includes our monthly newsletter with tasting notes, cigar maker profiles, tobacco blend specifications, drink pairing recommendations, and more.

Plus, each shipment is carefully packed with a reusable humidification device to ensure optimal humidity while your cigars are in transit and after they reach you.

Sourcing Cigars – On Location!

Each year, our 9-member panel of tobacconists collectively spends nearly half a year in man hours in Honduras, Nicaragua, and the Dominican Republic working with manufacturers to refine new blends. They sample over 12,000 cigars per year and review each for appearance, aroma & flavor, draw and construction – ensuring only well-made, superior cigars are selected for the club.

Reorder Your Favorite Cigars

Found some cigars you just have to have more of? No problem! Members enjoy discounted pricing on 5-packs and full boxes of their favorite featured cigars.

A Taste of Recent Shipments

Here's a sample of cigars we've recently featured.

Rocky Patel 15th Anniversary Toro - Pack of 5
  • Country Nicaragua
  • Strength 5 
Graycliff Profesionale Series Pirate - Pack of 5
  • Country Honduras
  • Strength 6 
Caldwell Collection - The King Is Dead Premier - Pack of 5
  • Country Dominican Republic
  • Strength 6 
H. Upmann Nicaragua Heritage by AJ Fernandez Toro - Pack of 5
  • Country Nicaragua
  • Strength 8 
AVO Heritage Robusto - Pack of 5
  • Country Dominican Republic
  • Strength 8 
Montecristo Espada Estoque - Pack of 5
  • Country Nicaragua
  • Strength 9.5 
Man O’ War Valkyrie Toro - Pack of 5
  • Country Nicaragua
  • Strength 4 
Zino Platinum Scepter Series Grand Master - Pack of 5
  • Country Dominican Republic
  • Strength 3 
Romeo y Julieta Reserva Real Robusto - Pack of 5
  • Country Dominican Republic
  • Strength 3 
CAO Black Frontier - Pack of 5
  • Country Honduras
  • Strength 5 
Diesel Wicked Torpedo - Pack of 5
  • Country Nicaragua
  • Strength 9 
Camacho Pre-Embargo Toro - Pack of 5
  • Country Honduras
  • Strength 8 
A. Flores 1975 Serie Privada Maduro SP52 - Pack of 5
  • Country Dominican Republic
  • Strength 6 
Gurkha Centurian Double Perfecto - Pack of 5
  • Country Dominican Republic
  • Strength 5 
Room 101 Farce Connecticut Super Toro - Pack of 5
  • Country Dominican Republic
  • Strength 3 
Drew Estate Blackened Shade to Black S84 Toro - Pack of 5
  • Country Nicaragua
  • Strength 6 
Cigar of the Month Club

More Than Cigars, It’s a Discovery

You or your gift recipient will enjoy:

  • Both Boutique & Super Premium Cigars
  • Hand-Rolled Cigars at Exceptional Values
  • Variety by Region, Brand and Blend
  • Detailed Tasting Notes and Manufacturer/Brand Profiles
  • Re-order Your Favorites at Substantial Discounts
  • Flexible Gift Ordering – Personalized Gift Message

Our nine-member panel of professional tobacconists takes its job seriously. Their 50 combined years of experience in the tobacco industry ensures that you or your gift recipient will enjoy well-made, superior cigars.

We smoke over 12,000 cigars per year so you don’t have to, rating each for appearance, flavor profile, aroma, smoke volume and construction. And we stand by every cigar we’ll send you.

Cigar of the Month Club

The Premium Cigar
of the Month Club

Customer Reviews

  • 5 stars: 181 (85%)
  • 4 stars: 28 (13%)
  • 3 stars: 4 (2%)
  • 2 stars: 0 (0%)
  • 1 star: 0 (0%)
F
Felipe S.
Great Cigars

I love the cigars. Nice variety and I can’t wait to see what I get this month.

T
Tim W.
Highly Recommend

Just starting back to smoking cigars after a short 35 years hiatus. I thought the Rare Cigar Club would be a great way to try some new sticks. It doesn't disappoint. Great selection, shipped with a Boveda so they are ready to smoke. They include a detailed description with each stick along with pairing suggestions. Great idea!

H
Heather M.
As a gift from my

As a gift from my wife I was always looking forward to see what I would get next, never a disappointment. I enjoyed smoking cigars I would not think to buy and found a few favorites to add to my regulars.

M
Michelle G.
Perfect Gift for my husband!

This was a perfect gift for the guy who has everything. I appreciated the quick feedback and customer service with questions. He loves the cigars. Also the information sheets on the type and what to pair them with is really cool.

J
Juanita V.
Great taste! The best cigars

Great taste! The best cigars I’ve ever tasted!

B
Brian C.
Never disappointed

I haven't received a bad order yet. Every cigar had been exactly as advertised, and make excellent gifts

D
Delois D.
It was a gift for

It was a gift for my son and he is very pleased with what he has received so far!

C
Cris M.
Amazing

I bought this for my brother in-law for his birthday. He got the first shipment very quickly and was very excited. Of course the excitement really came when he smoked the first. He told me he fell in love. So there you go a successful gift.

K
Kevin S.
Enjoyable Cigars

Always enjoy a good cigar, and these cigars are typically something not found in mainstream shops. Exceptional gift!

M
Megan C.
Great batch!

My father said this shipment was all great cigars. Thank you!

P
Patricia F.
The recipient was very happy

The recipient was very happy with the selection given.

A
Alisa D.
Cigar club

I ordered both the original premium and the rare cigar of the month club both were loved by the recipients . The cigars were great quality and excellent blends

J
Jason M.
A good introduction

If you’re new to cigars like I am, this is a great way to experience different “sticks”. I was very pleased with 2 cigars and left pretty dissatisfied with the rest. The cigars were fresh, in great shape, and mostly higher rated however. I am now narrowing down what I really enjoy and focusing on that style specifically. Maduro seems to be my favorite at this point.

M
Mark T.
Cigar

They were excellent. Great selection.

J
Jonathan J.
Great everytime

No complaints will order again

B
Bonnie B.
My son says they are

My son says they are all wonderful cigars

A
Alexis B.
Great Cigars!

All have arrived in perfect shape and are great quality. Would have been nice if I could have put in some preferences for a more curated subscription. Got this for a Father's day present and my dad loves it!

L
Lupe H.
So far all the cigars

So far all the cigars have been very good. I can’t wait for the next shipment.

B
BreAnn S.
Dad loves these ciga4s and

Dad loves these ciga4s and has asked for the subscription again!

E
Emily W.
Love the variety so far !

These cigars are always fresh and I’m always excited to see which ones are coming next.

A
Ann N.
Awesomeness

Awesomeness

L
Laurie K.
Great Gift!

A coworker and I ordered 3 months of these for our boss’s Christmas gift! He loves them!

B
Brent O.
Enjoyed the cigars immensely

Enjoyed the cigars immensely

D
Daniel B.
Nice variety and quality of

Nice variety and quality of cigars timely delivered

S
Shon H.
I love trying cigars that

I love trying cigars that I’d never have access to living in a small town. It’s like my birthday every month!

C
Cody Z.
NEVER Doubt This Club

I’m guilty of opening a delivery and thinking they dropped the ball that month and sent mediocre cigars. Then, I smoke them. I’ll never doubt this club again.

j
janet w.
This is the third year

This is the third year he has received this as a gift! He LOVES receiving it & being able to learn & enjoy so many different types of cigars, learn what they pair with, where they come from, etc. He enjoys the summary that ships w/them & looks forward to each shipment :)

R
Robyn S.
A Very Well Received Gift

When I was a little girl my father used to smoke cigars. I LOVED the smell. He quit for 4 decades or so and just recently picked it up again. For Christmas I gifted him four hand rolled cigars to see if they were to his liking. He loved each one and it now has become a custom for him to call me with each new one he smokes. He will receive his next pack for his birthday in February.

J
Jamie B.
My husband loved it!

My husband loved it!

D
Danielle F.
GIFT THIS CIGAR CLUB TO A CIGAR LOVER!

This was an easy gift to give a cigar lover. My boss loves cigars and was very impressed with the quality in his first delivery. More to follow, but I highly recommend the "rare premium" selection as he loves it and I trust his judgement~!

M
Michael M.
12/6/23 Cigar review

GREAT cigars that taste and burn really great!

J
Jodi P.
Excellent quality of cigars.

Excellent quality of cigars.

T
Timothy H.
Great Cigar Club

Fantastic selection of cigars with detailed tasting notes and pairing suggestions.

Frequently Asked Questions

Have questions? We got answers.